Protecting the Seller in an Earnout Agreement

An earnout may help buyers and sellers overcome differences in their expectations about future business performance. However, agreeing on the earnout amount represents only the beginning. After closing, the seller typically gives the buyer control over the business. That changes creates significant risk for contingent consideration. For this reason, seller earnout protection should address both the payment formula and the buyer’s post-closing operation of the company.

Before accepting an earnout, sellers should first evaluate the buyer. Financial strength matters because an earnout has little value without the ability to pay. Operating capabilities deserve similar attention. A buyer that cannot successfully manage the acquired company may reduce the probability of achieving performance targets. Sellers should also understand the buyer’s plans for the business. Changes involving employees, customers, pricing, suppliers, or investments could materially affect future results. Once comfortable with the buyer, the seller should focus carefully on the earnout provisions. Several areas deserve particular attention:

• Performance Measures: Define revenue, EBITDA, gross profit, or other measurements precisely.
• Accounting Policies: Establish consistent accounting methods for calculating performance throughout the earnout period.
• Operating Covenants: Address significant actions that could unfairly reduce or shift the company’s reported performance.
• Information Rights: Give the seller appropriate access to financial information supporting earnout calculations.
• Payment Terms: Clearly establish measurement dates, payment dates, and procedures for calculating amounts owed.
• Dispute Resolution: Establish a practical process for resolving disagreements, including independent accounting review when appropriate.
• Buyer Creditworthiness: Consider available protections when future payment depends materially on the buyer’s financial condition.

The measurement period also requires careful consideration. Longer periods increase uncertainty because business conditions and buyer strategies can change. Even strong contractual provisions will not eliminate every risk. Therefore, sellers should evaluate earnout consideration differently from cash received at closing. More fundamentally, the earnout should align the economic interests of both parties. A buyer should not benefit from preventing the seller from achieving reasonable performance objectives.

Effective seller earnout protection begins during negotiations, not after a disagreement develops. The M&A advisor should coordinate closely with legal, accounting, and tax professionals when evaluating the provisions. Earnouts may help bridge valuation gaps and complete transactions that might otherwise fail. However, their value depends on the seller’s ability to earn, verify, and collect the promised consideration.