Tag Archive for: AllstonAdvisoryGroup

How Working Capital Affects Proceeds at Closing

Many business sales occur on a cash-free, debt-free basis. However, the buyer still expects sufficient working capital to operate the business after closing. This expectation creates one of the most frequently negotiated components of a transaction: the working capital target.

The target establishes the amount of working capital the seller must effectively deliver at closing. Any difference between actual working capital and the target generally creates a purchase price adjustment.

Defining Working Capital

For transaction purposes, working capital usually includes selected operating current assets and current liabilities. Accounts receivable, inventory, accounts payable, and accrued expenses commonly enter the calculation. Cash and funded debt are typically excluded because the transaction addresses those items separately. Other accounts require careful consideration. Customer deposits, prepaid expenses, deferred revenue, accrued payroll, and related-party balances may create disagreements.

At the negotiating table, the parties should clearly define which accounts belong in the calculation. They should also establish consistent accounting policies for measuring those accounts.

Establishing the Target

The working capital target should reflect the amount reasonably necessary to operate the business under normal conditions. Historical averages often provide a useful starting point. However, the selected measurement period should reflect seasonality, growth, unusual events, and recent operating changes.

A trailing twelve month average may work for one company but distort another company’s requirements. Depending on the business cycle, monthly or quarterly analysis may provide a clearer picture. Sellers should also examine working capital relative to revenue when growth materially affects operating needs. Industry benchmarks may provide context, but company-specific history usually deserves greater weight.

Avoiding Surprises at Closing

Working capital often changes significantly between the LOI and closing. Receivables get collected, inventory moves, vendors receive payments, and new liabilities arise. Accordingly, sellers should model the expected closing balance well before the transaction closes. The LOI should address the working capital methodology whenever possible. Waiting until the purchase agreement may create unnecessary disputes after the seller has granted exclusivity.

An experienced M&A advisor should coordinate the analysis with the seller’s accounting and legal advisors. The team should define accounts, identify unusual balances, and establish a defensible target. A properly structured working capital target helps ensure the buyer receives a normally operating business. It also protects the seller from an unexpected reduction in proceeds at closing.

Managing Due Diligence After the Letter of Intent

The execution of a Letter of Intent marks a significant transition in the M&A process. At that point, the selected buyer typically receives exclusivity. The seller stops discussions with other prospective buyers while the selected buyer completes confirmatory M&A due diligence. Therefore, the transaction enters a different negotiating environment.

Before the LOI, multiple buyers may compete for the opportunity. That competition may strengthen the seller’s negotiating position on price, structure, and other terms. After exclusivity begins, that competitive pressure disappears. The buyer then conducts an extensive review before signing the definitive purchase agreement and closing the transaction.

The primary purpose of confirmatory M&A due diligence is to verify the information presented during the sale process. Buyers also investigate risks that could affect their investment. The review generally covers several major areas:

  • Financial: Revenue, earnings, normalized EBITDA, working capital, receivables, inventory, debt, and financial projections.
  • Legal: Contracts, corporate records, litigation, intellectual property, licenses, insurance, and regulatory compliance.
  • Operational: Facilities, equipment, technology, systems, suppliers, processes, and capital expenditure requirements.
  • Commercial: Customers, concentration, retention, pricing, competition, market position, and growth opportunities.
  • Human Resources: Management, employees, compensation, benefits, agreements, and organizational structure.
  • Tax: Income, payroll, sales, property, and other applicable tax matters.

The buyer may also conduct specialized reviews involving cybersecurity, environmental matters, insurance, or other industry-specific risks. During diligence, the buyer compares its findings with the information provided before signing the LOI. Significant differences may create problems for the seller. For example, declining earnings may challenge the assumptions supporting the purchase price. Customer losses or unexpected liabilities may create similar concerns.

In response, the buyer may seek a price reduction, additional escrow, stronger indemnification, or other changes. Significant findings may also prevent the transaction from closing. This possibility makes preparation before the LOI critical. Sellers should identify potential diligence issues before prospective buyers evaluate the company.

Financial statements should reconcile with supporting records and income tax returns. Contracts, employee matters, customer concentration, ownership records, and other significant issues should receive similar attention. When possible, the seller should correct problems before beginning the sale process. Otherwise, material issues should receive appropriate disclosure before the buyer receives exclusivity.

This approach protects credibility and reduces the likelihood of unexpected discoveries during confirmatory M&A due diligence. It also helps preserve the economics negotiated during the competitive process.

An experienced M&A advisor should anticipate diligence issues well before selecting a buyer. Careful preparation allows confirmatory diligence to validate the transaction rather than become an opportunity to renegotiate it.

Private Capital Markets: Is Now the Time to Sell?

The private capital markets are experiencing strong transaction activity, favorable valuations, and significant demand for quality middle market companies. For business owners considering an exit, current conditions deserve careful attention. Robert T. Slee, an investment banker and influential author, examines private market cycles in Private Capital Markets: Valuation, Capitalization, and Transfer of Private Business Interests. Slee’s research suggests that U.S. private markets operate within approximately ten-year transfer cycles.

According to this framework, the market currently favors sellers. Strong earnings, available financing, and significant buyer demand continue to support attractive valuations for quality businesses. However, favorable market conditions rarely continue indefinitely. Slee’s market-cycle analysis suggests this seller’s market may begin weakening toward the end of 2017. Thereafter, the market could enter a period of uncertainty through approximately 2020. The framework anticipates a buyer’s market following that neutral period. Under this scenario, weaker conditions could continue through approximately 2023 before the cycle begins strengthening again.

Meanwhile, several factors continue supporting today’s active M&A environment.

Private equity groups maintain substantial capital (“dry powder”) available for acquisitions and continue pursuing quality companies. In particular, they seek businesses with sustainable cash flows, strong management teams, defensible market positions, and meaningful growth opportunities. At the same time, strategic buyers continue using acquisitions to supplement organic growth. Acquisitions may provide immediate access to customers, geographic markets, products, technologies, employees, and other strategic capabilities. Demographic trends create another important consideration within the private capital markets. A significant population of middle market business owners are approaching traditional retirement age. Consequently, more owners may pursue liquidity and succession strategies during the coming years.

An increasing supply of businesses for sale could eventually affect market dynamics. More sellers competing for buyer attention may place pressure on valuations, particularly if economic conditions or financing markets weaken. For business owners, these trends reinforce the importance of early exit planning. Preparing a company for sale may require several years of deliberate work. Owners should strengthen earnings, develop management, diversify customers, improve financial reporting, and address identifiable business risks. They should also establish realistic valuation expectations and clearly define their personal and financial objectives.

No business owner can perfectly predict the next market cycle. Nevertheless, understanding conditions within the private capital markets will help owners make informed decisions about timing. For owners considering an exit within the next several years, 2016 provides an important opportunity to evaluate their alternatives. Early preparation creates flexibility and positions owners to act while market conditions remain favorable. Whether it’s selling to a private equity group, a strategic, or watching your “baby” flourish, Allston Advisory Group has the experience to assist you with the desired transaction for your business.

Choosing the Right Process to Sell a Business

Preparing a company for sale may significantly improve its financial performance, reduce risk, and strengthen its value drivers. For many businesses, this preparation has the greatest influence on transaction value. Once the company is ready for market, the business sale process becomes another significant factor in the outcome. The process determines how prospective buyers encounter the opportunity, compete for it, and negotiate transaction terms.

A well-designed process may create competitive tension while protecting confidentiality and preserving negotiating leverage. It may also help the seller identify which buyers place the greatest value on the business. The appropriate approach depends on the company, buyer universe, market conditions, and seller’s objectives. Most lower middle market transactions generally follow one of three approaches.

Broad Auction

A broad auction introduces the company to a relatively large group of qualified prospective buyers. These buyers may include strategic acquirers, private equity firms, family offices, and other financial buyers. This approach works particularly well when many credible buyers could have an interest in the company.

With a wider field, the seller may compare multiple offers and allow competition to influence price and transaction terms. However, broader outreach also requires careful confidentiality controls. The M&A advisor must qualify buyers and manage information throughout the process.

Targeted Auction

A targeted auction focuses on a smaller group of buyers with compelling reasons to pursue the company. The advisor identifies prospective buyers based on strategic fit, acquisition criteria, financial capacity, and likely interest. Through this narrower approach, the seller may preserve many benefits of competition while limiting unnecessary market exposure. A targeted auction may work especially well when the likely buyer universe is identifiable or confidentiality requires greater control.

Negotiated Sale

A negotiated sale involves discussions with one buyer or a very limited group of buyers. This approach sometimes begins with an unsolicited offer from a strategic acquirer. The process may offer greater confidentiality and potentially move faster. However, limited competition may reduce the seller’s negotiating leverage. In this situation, the seller must understand the company’s value and establish acceptable transaction terms before granting exclusivity.

Matching the Process to the Seller

No single business sale process works for every company. The appropriate strategy depends on buyer demand, confidentiality, market conditions, and seller objectives. An experienced M&A advisor should evaluate the likely buyer universe before recommending an approach. The advisor may then structure the process around the company’s specific circumstances.

A strong company creates value. The right sale process gives the marketplace an opportunity to recognize and compete for that value.

Using KPIs to Build a Stronger and More Valuable Business

Business owners cannot manage their companies effectively without understanding what drives financial and operational performance. Financial statements provide essential information, but they primarily explain what has already happened. Business performance indicators help management anticipate what may happen next. Key Performance Indicators, or KPIs, measure the activities and results that matter most to a company’s success.

Start With Financial Performance

Every owner should regularly review the income statement, balance sheet, and cash flow. However, reviewing individual months provides only part of the picture. Management should compare current results with budgets, prior periods, and historical trends. Industry benchmarks may also provide useful context when reliable comparisons exist.

Financial KPIs may include revenue growth, gross margin, EBITDA margin, days sales outstanding (DSO), and working capital. Alongside these measures, owners should identify the operational factors that produce financial results.

Identify Leading Indicators

Some of the most valuable KPIs appear before changes reach the financial statements. A contractor might monitor backlog, bids submitted, win rates, and project margins. A service company might track recurring revenue, customer retention, utilization, and new customer acquisition. A manufacturer could monitor capacity utilization, scrap rates, throughput, order volume, and on-time delivery. Earlier in the performance cycle, these indicators can provide warning signs or identify emerging opportunities.

Owners should ask a simple question: What would change first if our business started getting better or worse? The answer often identifies the company’s most useful leading indicators.

Turn Information Into Action

Tracking KPIs creates little value unless management acts on the information. Companies should establish targets, assign accountability, and review results consistently. Management may then investigate meaningful variances and determine appropriate responses.

When patterns emerge, leaders may adjust pricing, staffing, inventory, marketing, capital spending, or other operating decisions. A concise dashboard may keep management focused on the measures that matter most. Too many KPIs may obscure meaningful information rather than improve decision-making.

KPIs Support Business Value

Buyers want to understand more than historical earnings. They also want evidence explaining how the company generates those earnings. Well-developed business performance indicators demonstrate operating discipline, management depth, predictable performance, and visibility into future results.

For an owner preparing for a sale, KPIs can also strengthen the company’s investment story. They provide measurable evidence supporting growth trends, competitive advantages, and future opportunities. An experienced M&A advisor should identify the KPIs that prospective buyers will find most relevant. The advisor may then analyze historical trends and connect operating performance to the company’s financial results.

As sale preparations advance, the advisor may incorporate these measures into the Confidential Information Memorandum and other buyer materials. This analysis helps buyers understand what drives revenue, margins, and future earnings. KPIs also support management projections by connecting forecasted results to measurable operating assumptions. During due diligence, consistent KPI reporting help validate those assumptions and explain changes in performance.

An M&A advisor may also identify unfavorable trends before buyers discover them. Management then has time to investigate the causes, address problems, and prepared credible explanations. Strong businesses do not simply report financial results. They understand the operating factors behind those results. An experienced M&A advisor uses KPIs to help buyers understand those drivers and recognize the value they create.

Why the Purpose of a Business Valuation Matters

Business owners often ask what their companies are worth. However, that question does not have one answer for every circumstance. The purpose of a business valuation helps determine the appropriate engagement, standard of value, assumptions, and level of analysis. A valuation prepared for estate planning may differ significantly from an analysis supporting a potential business sale. Likewise, litigation or shareholder matters may require different assumptions and standards.

Different Decisions Require Different Valuations

Business valuations serve many financial, legal, tax, and transaction purposes. Common applications include estate and gift planning, shareholder transactions, buy-sell agreements, litigation, and employee ownership plans. Valuations may also support charitable contributions, purchase price allocations, and other financial decisions.

Given these different purposes, owners should define the valuation question before beginning the analysis. The applicable standard of value may include fair market value, fair value, or investment value. Each addresses a different question and may produce a different conclusion.

Valuation Before a Business Sale

A preliminary business valuation establishes a reference point for current value. It may also reveal a gap between estimated proceeds and the owner’s financial objectives. When a gap appears, the owner may decide that additional preparation is necessary before pursuing a transaction.

At that point, an Exit Readiness Assessment may provide a broader evaluation of the company from a prospective buyer’s perspective. The assessment may examine earnings quality, growth, customer concentration, management depth, operations, and other significant value drivers.

Together, the valuation and Exit Readiness Assessment serve different but complementary purposes. The valuation establishes where the business stands financially. The Exit Readiness Assessment helps identify what the owner should address before going to market.

Buyers May See Different Values

Prospective buyers do not necessarily value the same company equally. A financial buyer may focus heavily on expected returns and financing capacity. A strategic buyer may identify synergies, capabilities, customers, or geographic opportunities unavailable to other buyers. Because buyer economics differ, a valuation should not establish an artificial ceiling on transaction value. A competitive sale process allows multiple buyers to evaluate the company from their own perspectives.

Selecting the Appropriate Engagement

Qualified valuation professionals may perform different types of engagements depending on the assignment. A valuation engagement develops a conclusion of value after applying appropriate valuation approaches and methods. A calculation engagement uses agreed approaches, methods, and procedures to develop a calculated value.

An experienced M&A advisor uses valuation analysis to help owners establish expectations and prepare for a potential transaction. Understanding the purpose of a business valuation comes first. The appropriate analysis should answer the owner’s specific question rather than produce a number without context.

BURGER KING® FRANCHISEE HAS BEEN ACQUIRED BY CARROLS

ABOUT THE TRANSACTION:

Carrols Restaurant Group, Inc. (“Carrols”) (Nasdaq: TAST) has acquired six BURGER KING® restaurants from a Western Kentucky franchisee (the “Seller”).

The Seller has owned and operated six BURGER KING® restaurants located throughout Kentucky and Indiana. Collectively, the restaurants employ nearly 180 people and serve an established customer base across their respective markets.

Over the last 30 years, the Seller has developed a successful restaurant operation and built an experienced workforce. Additionally, the business has established loyal customer relationships that support consistent operations across its six locations.

STRATEGIC RATIONALE FOR CARROLS:

Headquartered in Syracuse, New York, Carrols is the largest BURGER KING® franchisee in the United States. The company operates more than 700 restaurants across 16 states and has operated BURGER KING® restaurants since 1976.

Carrols has maintained an active acquisition strategy focused on expanding its restaurant portfolio. The company has pursued franchise acquisitions that complement its geographic footprint and established operating infrastructure. Notably, Carrols has acquired the franchisor’s right of first refusal across 20 states, including Kentucky and Indiana. This position has made Carrols a particularly relevant strategic buyer for the Seller’s restaurant portfolio.

The acquisition has expanded Carrols’ presence within Kentucky and Indiana. Moreover, the transaction provides opportunities to integrate the restaurants into Carrols’ established operating platform. Carrols also expects the acquired restaurants to benefit from its purchasing power, management infrastructure, and operating experience. These capabilities support the buyer’s objectives of capturing operational synergies and improving restaurant profitability.

ALLSTON ADVISORY GROUP’S ROLE:

Allston Advisory Group served as the exclusive financial advisor to the Seller. The firm performed an Analysis of Value for the restaurant portfolio and prepared a comprehensive Confidential Information Memorandum. Furthermore, Allston evaluated the market and identified prospective strategic and financial buyers for the restaurant holdings. Given Carrols’ acquisition strategy, Allston identified the company as a compelling strategic buyer for the portfolio.

Thereafter, Allston approached Carrols and managed the confidential sale process on behalf of the Seller. The firm coordinated communications, facilitated negotiations, and assisted the parties throughout due diligence. Ultimately, the transaction has accomplished the Seller’s objective of obtaining liquidity from his BURGER KING® restaurant holdings. Equally important, employees have transitioned to an established and well-capitalized restaurant operator.

As a result, the acquisition has supported Carrols’ continued geographic expansion and provides additional opportunities to capture operating efficiencies. The transaction represents a strategic combination that addresses the objectives of both buyer and seller.

ABOUT ALLSTON ADVISORY GROUP:

Allston Advisory Group is an independent mergers and acquisitions advisory firm serving lower middle market businesses throughout the United States. The firm provides sell-side advisory, business valuations, and exit planning services across diverse industries. Allston combines transaction expertise with personalized client service to help business owners maximize value and achieve successful outcomes.

For additional information on this transaction, please contact one of our advisors.

NEWS SOURCES:

From Letter of Intent to the Definitive Purchase Agreement

After completing confirmatory due diligence, the parties move toward finalizing the purchase agreement. This definitive agreement governs the transaction and establishes each party’s binding obligations. The Letter of Intent provides the framework for these negotiations. It generally outlines purchase price, structure, consideration, working capital, and other principal business terms. The purchase agreement goes considerably further. It converts negotiated terms into detailed contractual provisions and addresses risks identified during due diligence.

Although transaction attorneys draft and negotiate the agreement, many provisions involve significant business decisions. Sellers should therefore understand the economic consequences behind the legal language. A typical purchase agreement addresses three broad areas:

  • Transaction Economics: Purchase price, consideration, payment timing, earnouts, seller notes, rollover equity, and post-closing adjustments.
  • Closing Mechanics: Closing conditions, required consents, covenants, financing requirements, schedules, and procedures for completing the transaction.
  • Risk Allocation: Representations, warranties, indemnification, escrows, holdbacks, baskets, caps, survival periods, and dispute procedures.

The agreement also defines exactly what the buyer acquires. In an asset sale, it identifies purchased assets and assumed liabilities. By comparison, an equity transaction transfers ownership interests in the legal entity. The agreement must still address excluded obligations and other negotiated protections.

Working capital frequently receives significant attention during negotiations. The agreement establishes the target, calculation methodology, and process for resolving post-closing differences. Representations and warranties serve another purpose. They provide factual statements about the company, its operations, financial condition, contracts, employees, taxes, and other matters. Disclosure schedules then qualify those representations by identifying exceptions. Accurate schedules help sellers disclose known issues and reduce potential post-closing disputes.

Once negotiations reach this stage, the transaction attorney takes the lead on legal documentation. However, the attorney should not work independently from the broader M&A team. The M&A advisor helps ensure the agreement accurately reflects the business terms negotiated in the LOI. The advisor also evaluates proposed changes affecting purchase price, consideration, working capital, and other economics. Meanwhile, the seller’s CPA and tax advisor evaluate accounting and tax provisions. Their input may become particularly valuable when addressing allocations, working capital, and transaction structure.

New issues may still emerge before closing. When they do, the advisory team should evaluate their legal, financial, and economic consequences together. A well-negotiated purchase agreement does more than document the sale. It preserves negotiated economics, allocates transaction risk, and establishes clear obligations through closing and beyond.

Creating Buyer Competition in a Business Sale

A business owner negotiating with one buyer has limited information about what the broader marketplace may offer. The buyer knows this as well. A competitive buyer process changes that dynamic by creating alternatives for the seller. Multiple qualified buyers strengthen negotiating leverage and provide meaningful comparisons among offers. However, generating a long buyer list does not create competition by itself. The M&A advisor must identify buyers with the interest, resources, and strategic rationale to complete the transaction.

Build the Right Buyer Universe

The process begins by understanding the company and identifying potential sources of buyer demand. Strategic buyers may seek new customers, geographic markets, products, employees, technology, or operating capabilities. Private equity firms evaluate opportunities based on their investment criteria, portfolio strategies, expected returns, and available capital. Well-funded individual buyers and family offices may also represent credible candidates for certain companies.

At the buyer-development stage, the advisor should look beyond obvious industry participants. Buyers from adjacent markets may identify opportunities that direct competitors overlook.

Qualify Buyers Before Sharing Information

More buyers do not necessarily create a better process. Qualified buyers do. An experienced M&A advisor should evaluate financial capacity, acquisition criteria, transaction experience, strategic rationale, and decision-making authority. This qualification helps separate serious prospects from tire kickers.

After establishing credibility, qualified buyers receive the Confidential Information Memorandum (CIM) following execution of a confidentiality agreement. The CIM should present the company’s financial performance, operations, competitive position, and growth opportunities clearly.

Create Competition Through Process

Competition requires more than contacting buyers. The advisor must manage those buyers through a coordinated process. Deadlines for indications of interest encourage buyers to make decisions within a defined timeframe. Comparable offers also allow the seller to evaluate price, structure, certainty, and post-closing terms.

As buyer interest develops, the advisor negotiates from a position supported by credible alternatives. One buyer may offer the highest price. Another may provide more cash, fewer contingencies, or better terms for the seller.

Preserve Competition Until the LOI

The seller’s leverage generally reaches a critical point before granting exclusivity to one buyer. An experienced M&A advisor should use the competitive buyer process to resolve significant economic terms before that occurs. The objective is not simply to generate multiple buyers. It is to create a marketplace where qualified buyers compete for the opportunity.

Competition gives the seller alternatives, and alternatives create negotiating leverage.

Setting the Deal Framework in the Letter of Intent

A Letter of Intent marks a significant transition in the sale of a business. It moves the parties from preliminary discussions toward a defined transaction. The LOI should establish the principal business terms before the parties commit substantial resources to completing the deal. Most provisions remain nonbinding. However, certain provisions, including confidentiality and exclusivity, may create binding obligations.

Define the Transaction Economics

The purchase price represents only one component of an offer. Sellers should understand how and when they will receive the consideration. Accordingly, LOI deal terms should address purchase price, transaction structure, and the form of consideration. The LOI may also address seller financing, earnouts, rollover equity, escrows, and other holdbacks.

Working capital deserves particular attention. The parties should establish the methodology for determining the working capital target and any resulting adjustment. At this point in the negotiations, the parties should also identify whether the transaction involves an asset or equity purchase.

Address the Seller’s Continuing Involvement

Many transactions require the seller to remain involved after closing. The LOI should address significant expectations concerning employment, consulting, transition assistance, or continuing ownership. Compensation and responsibilities may also require discussion when the seller remains employed. Similarly, the parties should identify material noncompetition or non-solicitation expectations before proceeding.

Establish the Path to Closing

The LOI should provide a framework for moving from agreement to closing. This framework may address due diligence, financing, regulatory approvals, closing conditions, and the anticipated closing date. Before the process narrows, the seller should also understand the exclusivity period. During exclusivity, the seller generally stops discussions with competing buyers. The buyer then conducts confirmatory due diligence and negotiates the definitive purchase agreement.

Resolve Major Issues Early

The LOI cannot anticipate every provision contained in the final purchase agreement. Trying to negotiate every legal detail at this stage would also defeat its purpose. However, leaving significant economic issues unresolved may create problems later.

An experienced M&A advisor should negotiate the LOI deal terms with the entire transaction in mind. The advisor can identify economic issues that deserve resolution before exclusivity begins. Legal counsel should review the LOI before execution and address its binding and nonbinding provisions. A well-structured LOI does more than summarize an offer. It establishes the economic framework and provides a clear path toward the definitive purchase agreement.