APPEARANCE MATTERS?

The physical appearance of a business’ equipment and facilities, including office, manufacturing, and warehousing space, weighs heavily with prospective buyers and must be consistent with the purchase price. Business owners who are determined to receive a premium for their business have to consider the inherent value of a fresh coat of paint, clean workspaces, an organized warehouse, and well-maintained equipment prior to the initiation of the sales process. This may also be a great time to review and update the business logo, website and marketing materials. Simply stated, a business being sold for millions of dollars should look like a million bucks!

Organized facilities and systematically-maintained equipment conveys the message that the business’ routine affairs are in order. This includes but is not limited to inventory counts, receivables/payables, financial records, and compliance records. It also suggests to prospective buyers that the necessary capital investments have been made to sustain the future growth of the business.

A small investment towards the appearance of a business improves its marketability and increases its appeal to prospective buyers.

BARRIERS TO ENTRY: BUILD A WALL!!!

Business owners must “build a wall” around their businesses to avoid advances from would-be competitors, and reinforce their position in the market. Barriers to entry deter new competitors from entering a market, secure the revenues and profitability of established companies, and increase the value of protected businesses. Consequently, businesses with high barriers to entry reduce their perceived risk and command premium prices from prospective buyers. To sideline aspiring competitors, consider the following barriers to entry:

  • Exclusive Agreements – with key suppliers, distributors or retailers; problematic for new entrants;
  • Economies of Scale – operational efficiencies, new technologies/processes, bulk pricing for materials; declines in unit cost allows price/profit flexibility;
  • Product Differentiation – brand identification, customer loyalty; requires major advertising spend from prospective competitors to overcome;
  • Intellectual Property – patents, trademarks, copyrights, trade/brand names, proprietary products/services, customized databases/designs, innovative product technology;
  • Switching Costs – difficult/expensive for customers to switch providers;
  • The Network Effect – value of product or service increases with each additional new/existing customer;

When updating your business plan, consider evaluating the barriers to entry with the assistance of your investments banker for the purposes of maximizing the current and future value of your business.

BRAND RECOGNITION ENHANCES VALUE?

Early orchestration of a strategy for your business’ brand will create additional value at the time your business is sold. A brand represents the face of the business; a unique and recognizable design, sign, symbol, or slogan employed to create an image that identifies a product and differentiates it from its competitors. Aside from generating increased revenues and profits, strong brand recognition and reputation may clearly drive higher multipliers of cash flow for the potential business value for these reasons:

  • Higher customer retention; repeat business; effects reliability of future sales and sustainability of existing customers
  • Competitive edge in the market; identifies your product/services, differentiates it from the competition
  • Higher barrier for competition; customer recognition of credibility, quality/satisfaction with the brand; possible protected intellectual property
  • Owner is less essential to business success; company’s reputation stands for certain benefits/value
  • Attraction/retention of employees and management; strong successor management in place
  • Loyal customers who insist on product by brand name; prepared to pay a premium for it
By investing in your business’ brand recognition and reputation, your business will be worth more. An experienced M&A Team can assist you with identifying and accentuating your business’ brand and value.

DRIVE VALUE THROUGH OPERATING SYSTEMS!

In addition to a knowledgeable and ambitious management team, developing innovative operating systems and procedures enhance the value of a business. Effective operating systems and procedures must be reliable, updated and maintained regularly, documented systematically, administered consistently, and adequate for growth of the business. Operating systems, or formalized business processes and procedures, are utilized most often to improve the sustainability of a business’ cash flows; therefore, a focus on rapid growth and value maximization requires a business owner to integrate sophisticated operating systems and procedures across multiple business functions. These systems may include:

  • Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) – streamlines back-office; accounting and financial applications, supply chain management, distribution, product/service planning and pricing
  • Customer Relationship Management (CRM) – manages/analyzes customer interactions and data; marketing, sales, service
  • Human Capital Management (HCM) – employee recruitment, hiring, scheduling, compensation, benefits, development, performance
  • Enterprise Content Management (ECM) – organizes/stores documents relating to business processes

The most desirable businesses have the capabilities to maintain their profitability after a sale, and implementing standardized systems and procedures validate continued success to prospective buyers. A qualified investment banking team can provide initial direction for enhancing this value driver.

MANAGEMENT TEAM: EXIT WITH A DEEP BENCH!

An experienced, motivated and stable management team is the most significant value driver of M&A transactions. Businesses with a strong management team focus on the sustained growth of cash flows and profitability, command higher valuations in the marketplace, and allow for the seamless exit of the owners.

In the eyes of prospective buyers, there is no greater reassurance of continued business success than a talented management team. Therefore, business owners should consider the following while acquiring and developing their team:

  • Clearly defined job description, roles and responsibilities
  • Documented and measurable employee assessments
  • Alignment of employee goals with company goals
  • Non-compete or non-solicitation agreements
  • Performance incentives and stock ownership plans

Even if a business owner doesn’t exit their business for years to come or lacks a clearly defined exit strategy, a deep bench will accelerate growth, increase profits, and allow more time away from the office!

NOT FROM CONCENTRATE!

Client concentrations may be the curse of M&A transactions. They cultivate uneasiness with buyers due to the potential loss of revenue, and raise significant concerns with major lending institutions. If a substantial percentage of a business’s revenue is generated by a limited number of clients, buyers tend to have apprehension regarding future cash flows and withdraw from a potential sale. In my experience, it has always been difficult to turn away business in order to balance uneven client concentrations, especially in the start-up and growth phases of a business. However, business owners may prevent a future potential deal killer and value reducer by identifying the issue, knowing the long-term effect and solving the problem over time, including:

  • Focusing on profitability rather than revenue from a large client; the risks taken with high concentrations should be rewarded with greater profitability;
  • Developing strategies to mitigate client concentrations: set goals for reducing the percentages, increase sales to other clients;
  • Considering an acquisition; and
  • Entering new markets, begin diversifying revenue as quickly as possible.
Client concentrations are not an easy problem to solve; however, taking the steps to manage the risks will ensure the rewards outweigh the risks.

EARNOUTS: CREATING CONFUSION OR PROMOTING PROSPERITY?

Earnouts, although palatable in principle, may be complex in structure, difficult to define, and subject to unintended consequences. Thus, the gut reaction of most investment bankers to the proposed use of earnouts as an instrument to close transactions is unequivocally: “Don’t use them!” This declaration will more than likely be superseded by a full disclosure of the realities of the private capital marketplace. Earnouts are used every day in middle market mergers and acquisitions (M&A) transactions, and under the direction of an experienced M&A Team, properly structured earnouts provide motivated buyers and sellers with a viable solution to otherwise “dead deals.”

An earnout tends to be most impactful when it is used to:

  1. Provide Measurable Incentives – motivate sellers to be growth-focused post-closing; retain key employees; acquire new customers; renew contracts
  2. Align the Needs of Both Parties – reconcile value differences – historical versus projected financial performance
  3. Mitigate Risk – assure future earnings/growth; address uncertainties
Buyers and sellers have to be flexible throughout the negotiation process; relying on their M&A Team for guidance and experience to facilitate the design of an achievable earnout.

PROSPECTIVE BUYERS: WHAT’S THE SCENARIO?

The most desired transaction for lower middle market business owners contemplating the sale of their business requires deep consideration of the characteristics, motivations, and aspirations of the businesses’ prospective buyers. Customarily, strategic and financial buyers have the largest appetite for acquisitions in the private capital marketplace, and there are significant differences between the two buyer-types that necessitate further examination. Some of these differences include:

FINANCIAL BUYERS:
  • Includes private equity groups, holding companies, high net worth individuals;
  • Target single, cash-producing entities; attractive industries; high growth potential;
  • Focus on earnings growth; invest strictly to realize a financial return
STRATEGIC BUYERS:
  • Includes competitors, customers, suppliers, unrelated companies;
  • Established, operating businesses; possess industry experience/knowledge;
  • Focus on synergies/integration; increase long-term shareholder value;
  • Acquire to increase market share, expand geographically, gain technologies/key employees or diversify revenue streams

Two exits rarely follow the same path; however, it’s critical that the M&A Advisory Team understands your ‘perfect scenario.’ Financial buyer or strategic buyer – the knowledgeable investment bankers at Allston Advisory Group have the expertise and resources to customize a successful transaction process that captures your exit strategy objectives.

RESTRICTED STOCK AWARD PLANS

Ownership can be a powerful tool in the effort to attract and retain talented people, have employees think and act like owners, create an ownership culture, and build successful succession plans.

Restricted stock gives employees the right to earn shares of stock over some period of time through continued service or the accomplishment of certain goals. Restricted Stock Award (RSA) Plans have many options, and when properly designed, will provide your Company with an equity compensation plan that works. Advantages include:

  • Restricted Stock Award Plans either grant shares at no cost, or provides employees with the right to purchase shares at fair market value or at a discount.
  • RSA shares are subject to vesting requirements; vesting may occur all at once or gradually. The restrictions may be time, performance, and/or transaction based.
  • Restricted shares may be issued at grant; RSA shares remain subject to vesting restrictions; however, the shareholder receives dividends, has voting and other rights before vesting.
  • Employer may loan money to the awardees for purchase of the restricted shares. The RSA Plan gives key employees the ability to own shares.
In the M&A world, Restricted Stock Award Plans assist in the process of maximizing the value of your Company.

CIMS: A NEW PAIR OF GLASSES

Detailed Confidential Information Memorandums (CIMs) require collaboration between Sellers and their Investment Banker(s), and will provide prospective Buyers with enough information to make purchasing decisions. Highly effective CIMs consider the Buyers’ perspective throughout the preparation process; accordingly, CIMs must emphasize the value drivers of businesses and all decision-critical content and data. Motivated prospective Buyers expect at a minimum:

  • Comprehensive Financials – the most important information; preferably prepared by an independent CPA; normalized and recast; asset listing
  • Desired Transaction – ownership/key personnel post-transaction intentions; relationship transferability; outline buyer deliverables
  • Define the Core Business – value drivers; various revenue streams; unique processes, technologies, or equipment; niche focus
  • Major Contracts or Customers – diversified or concentrated; percentage of revenue; client loyalty
  • Marketplace & Growth Opportunities – strengths/ weaknesses; CAPEX requirements; growth vision

The mergers and acquisitions sale processes with the fewest “surprises” depend on meticulous planning and preparation. Therefore, it is imperative that Sellers and their M&A Team understand what prospective Buyers look for in businesses in order to construct the most impactful Confidential Information Memorandum.